Disadvantages of Filing for Divorce First

Filing for divorce first might seem like a strategic move, but it comes with potential downsides that can affect your case financially, emotionally, and legally. While initiating the process allows you to set the pace of the divorce, it also carries risks that must be considered. Here’s a detailed analysis of the disadvantages of being the first to file.

1. Higher Financial Costs

Filing for divorce first often means shouldering the initial financial burden of the divorce process. This can include:

• Filing Fees: Divorce filing fees can range from $100 to $500 or more, depending on the state.
• Attorney Retainers: Retainer fees are typically required upfront when you hire a lawyer to prepare and file the case.
• Service Costs: You are responsible for the cost of serving divorce papers to your spouse.

Additionally, by filing first, you may set the tone for a contested divorce, which could lead to prolonged litigation and higher legal expenses.

2. Emotional Stress and Pressure

Filing first places you in the position of driving the process, which can be emotionally taxing:

• You must decide on significant issues like child custody, property division, and spousal support before your spouse even responds.
• The pressure of initiating the process can create guilt, especially if your spouse is resistant or caught off guard.
• You may feel more responsible for the emotional fallout, particularly if children or family members are involved.

3. Risk of Retaliation

Filing first can lead to resentment or retaliation from your spouse, which might complicate the divorce. Examples include:

• Uncooperative Behavior: Your spouse might resist negotiations out of spite.
• Increased Litigation: A defensive reaction could result in prolonged legal battles.
• Aggressive Demands: They may counter-file or demand terms more aggressively.

In some cases, the adversarial tone set by filing first can make the divorce process more contentious.

4. Limited Time for Preparation

Filing first means you need to have your case and documentation ready early on. This includes:

• Gathering financial records such as bank statements, tax returns, and asset documentation.
• Determining your preferred outcomes for custody, support, and property division.
• Being ready for court hearings or mediation sessions soon after filing.

If you’re unprepared, filing first may weaken your negotiating position.

5. Loss of Strategic Flexibility

The first person to file may lose certain strategic advantages, such as:

• Responding to Claims: By filing first, you reveal your arguments and desired terms. Your spouse can counter these more effectively.
• Setting the Venue: While filing first usually determines the jurisdiction, your choice might not always be beneficial, especially if you and your spouse live in different states or regions with varying divorce laws.
• Rushed Decisions: You might feel pressure to finalize your claims quickly, potentially overlooking key details.

6. Possible Perception as the Aggressor

Being the first to file might create the impression that you are the one pushing for the divorce, even if it was a mutual decision. This can affect:

• Public Opinion: Friends and family may see you as the initiator, leading to potential judgment.
• Court Perception: While courts strive for impartiality, there’s a slight risk that a judge may perceive you as less willing to compromise.

7. Impact on Settlement Negotiations

When you file first, your spouse may assume you are ready for a fight, which could hinder cooperative negotiations. The adversarial tone might:

• Reduce the likelihood of amicable settlements.
• Increase the chances of the case going to trial.
• Create additional stress for both parties and any children involved.

Is Filing First Ever a Bad Idea?

Filing first may not always be the best option if:

1. You’re Not Fully Prepared: Without thorough documentation and a clear strategy, you risk making mistakes.
2. Your Spouse Is Willing to Cooperate: If your spouse is open to compromise, filing first could set an unnecessary adversarial tone.
3. You Lack Financial Resources: Taking on initial costs without support might strain your finances.

What Should You Do Instead?

If you’re hesitant about filing first, consider these alternatives:

1. Attempt Mediation or Counseling: Before escalating the process, try to resolve issues with professional help.
2. Consult an Attorney: Seek advice about whether filing first benefits your unique situation.
3. Gather Evidence and Plan Strategically: Even if you don’t file first, being prepared ensures you’re ready to respond effectively.

---

Filing for divorce first has both advantages and disadvantages, but the drawbacks can significantly impact your finances, emotions, and the divorce process overall. Before deciding, weigh your options carefully and consult a qualified family law attorney to ensure you’re making the best choice for your circumstances.